Plot: Apple Buck, Apple Bloom, Snails, Snips, and the Lost Kids had plenty of exciting adventures in Neverland and must outwit Edgar.


  • Peter Pan - Apple Buck (Equestria Boys)
  • Wendy Darling - Apple Bloom (Equestria Girls)
  • John Darling - Snails (Equestria Girls) (as Apple Bloom's big brother)
  • Michael Darling - Snips (Equestria Girls) (as Apple Bloom's little brother)
  • Tinker Bell - Pony Diamond Tiara (My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic)
  • Slightly the Fox Lostboy - Sugar Rush (Equestria Boys)
  • Cubby the Bear Lostboy - Charming Chime (Equestria Boys)
  • The Twins Lostboys -  Babs Seed, Sweetie Belle, and Scootaloo (Equestria Girls)
  • Nibs the Rabbit Lostboy - Silver Spoon (Equestria Girls)
  • Tootles the Skunk Lostboy - Pipsqueak (Equestria Girls)
  • Princess Tiger Lily - Human Diamond Tiara (Equestria Girls)
  • The Indian Chief - Judge Doom (Who Framed Roger Rabbit) (as a good guy and as Diamond Tiara's father)
  • The Indians - The Toon Patrol (Who Framed Roger Rabbit) (as good guys)
  • Mermaids - Rainbow Dash, Sunset Shimmer, Fluttershy, Applejack, Twilight Sparkle, Rarity, and Pinkie Pie (Equestria Girls)
  • Captain Hook - Edgar (The Aristocats)
  • Mr. Smee - Jasper and Horace (101 Dalmatians (animated)) (as Edgar's assistants)
  • Tic Toc the Crocodile - Discord (My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic)