Apple White as Mermaid 1
Ashlynn Ella as Mermaid 2
Briar Beauty as Mermaid 3
Cerise Hood as Mermaid 4
Clawdeen Wolf as Mermaid 5
Cleo De Nile as Mermaid 6
Draculaura as Mermaid 7
Frankie Stein as Mermaid 8
Ghoulia Yelps as Mermaid 9
Holly O'Hair as Mermaid 10
Lagoona Blue as Mermaid 11
Meeshell Mermaid as Mermaid 12
Raven Queen as Mermaid 13
Spectra Vondergeist as Mermaid 14
Captain Gutt as Pirate 1
Flynn, Gupta, Squint, Silas, Dobson, and Raz as Pirates 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 (Although Shera will not be in the story since she turned good in "Ice Age 4."
Count Bleck as Pirate 8/Reformed ally in the sequel 4
Dick Dastardly as Pirate 9
Muttley as Pirate 10
Merlock as Pirate 11
Dijon as Pirate 12
Dimentio as Pirate 13
Don Karnage as Pirate 14
Mad Dog, Gibber, and Dumptruck as Pirates 15, 16, and 17 (Even though Mad Dog is not in the picture, he and these two will be in the story)
Dr. Jacques Von Hamsterviel as Pirate 18
Drake as Pirate 19
Ernesto de la Cruz as Pirate 20
Hare as Pirate 21
Jenner as Pirate 22
Negaduck as Pirate 23
Bushroot as Pirate 24
Liquidator as Pirate 25
Megavolt as Pirate 26
Quackerjack as Pirate 27
Muska as Pirate 28
Rasputin as Pirate 29
Ratigan as Pirate 30
Rourke as Pirate 31 (Both in this outfit and the tanktop outfit in this story)
Scroop as Pirate 32
Slippery Sam as Pirate who Gets Killed Off (This is what he looks like for a goofy-looking pirate)