Plot: Gideon took Alice, Cody, and Edmond to Neverland and must stop Prince John from wreaking havoc.

GideonxAlice, CodyxSagwa (possibly), EdmondxMarie (sometimes), SinbadxCinderella, TiggerxTigress, Honest JohnxAurora, WilburxJasmine, Donald DuckxAriel, Jose CariocaxTiana, PoohxMulan, PigletxPocahontas


  • Peter Pan - Gideon (Pinocchio)
  • Wendy Darling - Alice (Alice in Wonderland (1951))
  • John Darling - Cody (The Rescuers Down Under) (as Alice's little brother)
  • Michael Darling - Edmond (Rock-A-Doodle) (as Alice's other little brother)
  • Tinker Bell - Marie (The Aristocats)
  • Captain Hook - Prince John (Robin Hood)
  • Mr. Smee - Sir Hiss (Robin Hood)
  • Tic-Toc the Crocodile - Shenzi, Banzai, and Ed (all three from The Lion King) (as Prince John's enemies)
  • The Lost Boys played by:
    • Slightly the Fox Lostboy - ​Honest John (Pinocchio)
    • Cubby the Bear Lostboy - Wilbur (The Rescuers Down Under)
    • The Twins Lostboys - Donald Duck and Jose Carioca (both from Disney)
    • Nibs the Rabbit Lostboy - Pooh (Winnie the Pooh)
    • Tootles the Skunk Lostboy - Piglet (Winnie the Pooh)
  • ​Princess Tiger Lily - Sagwa (Sagwa the Chinese Siamese Cat)
  • The Indian Chief - Cat R. Waul (An American Tail 2: Fievel Goes West) (as a good guy and as Sagwa's father)
  • Nana - Dinah (Alice in Wonderland (1951))
  • Extras with Dinah: Snipes, peepers, and Patou (all three from Rock-A-Doodle)
  • Mary Darling - Cinderella (Same as the movie) (as Alice's mother)
  • George Darling - Sinbad (Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas) (as Alice's father)
  • Red-Haired Mermaid - Aurora (Sleeping Beauty)
  • Black-Haired Mermaid - Jasmine (Aladdin)
  • Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Ariel (The Little Mermaid)
  • Other Red-Haired Mermaid - Tiana (The Princess and the Frog)
  • Other Black-Haired Mermaid - Mulan (Same as the movie)
  • Other Blonde-Haired Mermaid - Pocahontas (Same as the movie)
  • The Indians - Cat R. Waul's Henchmen (An American Tail 2: Fievel Goes West) (as good guys)
  • Indian Squaw - Jessica Rabbit (Who Framed Roger Rabbit)
  • Brave and Squaw - Tigger and Tigress (Winnie the Pooh and Kung Fu Panda)
  • Brave's Mother-in-Law - Zira (The Lion King II: Simba's Pride)
  • The Pirates - Rhino and Wolf Guards (Robin Hood)